Skip navigation

BBC NEWS | Asia-Pacific | New strain on Malaysia’s ethnic ties

This article was written before the elections. The assumption that relations between the government and the 2 million Indians is strained was very clearly shown in the election results.
The visa policy is a government to government matter and I don’t think there will be drastic changes to the rules governing Indians coming to work in Malaysia, as I look around a sizeable number of Indians are working in the cleaning sector particularly with the municipal councils and in other sectors and I think the labour force is doing it work diligently.
There is this wrong concept that the Hindraf rally was a move by the Indians to take away what is owned by the Malays. This is far from the truth. The problems highlighted by the rally was to bring attention to the government ills suffered by the Indians in regard to socio-economic shortcomings, it did not originate to show differences between the Malays or Chinese. The message was simple, we are part of the Malaysian community and we want to share part of the cake the government has got to offer without any reference to other races. It is purely an Indian problem. In relating the problems it might have been inevitable to show proof like how a Malay gets his license to do business without much fanfare, but the Indian has to undergo hassle and delay in getting the same document, but nowhere does the Indian blame the Malay for his predicament, but it is more with the Little Napoleons in the civil service who make the process difficult. Invariably the Little Napoleon may be a Malay, but the anger is not directed at the person as an individual but the government which controls the Little Napoleon. Hence it is wrong to say the Indians are angry with the Malays, but they are angry with the government for making life so difficult and MIC is blamed for not looking after the welfare of the Indians.
If there is any ethnic problem that exists it is because leaders are so free with their predictions violence will erupt for a problem between the Indian community and the government, it is nothing against any other race Malay, Chinese or otherwise.
May 13 was caused by the election defeat and the disturbances in Old Klang road were troubles that erupted between an Indian and Malay and escalated to communal proportions. These two cannot be used as a measure to say one community is ready to pounce on another. Indians, Malays and Chinese live in mixed areas, work together, study together etc but there is no underlying friction amongst them. They get along well,
It may be noticed that the communal groups follow the adage birds of a feather live together, by mixing only with their kind in housing estates and schools but this is brought about by the division of race, religion and politics depending on the colour of the skin that is spelled out by the government in race based political parties, different type of schools, employing one race in the civil race and so forth. The government does this for the political advantage of keeping the races segregated to ensure continuity in the management of the country, but the people are studying, living and working together, they have no problems.
It is the government that must act. For a start, no race based political parties, is the right thing to do. This enforced segregation must stop.
My neighbour is a Chinese, across me lives a Malay, we live peacefully, we are not waiting to pounce on one another, plotting day and night.
Observe the elections, Indians voted Malays and Chinese, Malays voted Chinese and Indians, Chinese voted Malays and Indians, does it show ethnic friction.   


New strain on Malaysia’s ethnic ties

By Robin Brant
BBC News, Kuala Lumpur

Pedestrians in Kuala Lumpur walk past a billboard displaying the city skyline (file photo)

Malaysia has been a culturally-mixed country since the 1800s

Relations are not good right now between the Malaysian government and the two million plus people living here who are descended from Indian migrants.

There is confusion over exactly what has happened in recent days, but if the government really has decided to tighten up its visa policy for all Indian migrant workers, it would be a startling diplomatic gesture.

Just as political leaders across the world are lining up to do deals with India, Malaysia appears to have gone the other way.

It is unexpected, to say the least.

India and Malaysia have a long history of close cultural, economic and political ties.

Indians migrated here in their thousands in the 1800s, to work the rubber plantations. There are now more than two million Malaysian Indians.

The big problem here that we have is that nobody trusts each other anymore

Manjit Bhatsia

But dissent has been brewing. It boiled over with a public protest last November – a rare thing here.

Thousands took to the streets to demonstrate, in defiance of a police ban.

The cabinet decision to suspend visas is proof that the event, with images of riot police and water cannons beamed around the world, has shaken those at the top of government.

They are worried – worried about instability and what it might do to the economy, and worried about the delicate coalition that is modern-day Malaysian society.

‘No trust’

Ethnic Chinese Malaysians at a temple in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia (14/10/2007)

Ethnic Chinese are reaping the rewards of the economic boom

Indians are one of the three dominant groups here.

The Chinese established communities over centuries. Together with the Malays they all make for a fragile but mostly harmonious mix.

This mix is in trouble now, though, according to Manjit Bhatsia, an academic and writer who was born in Malaysia but now lives and works in Australia.

“The big problem that we have is that nobody trusts each other anymore,” he said.

“There’s a working relationship, a very strong working relationship at the top level of society, but at every other level of society it just doesn’t work.

“That’s the problem, this administration needs to understand that it has created a monster.”

The root problem is the years of discrimination some Malaysian Indians say they have endured, accusing ethnic Malays of enjoying preferential treatment.

The underlying problems that we have can easily erupt between the communities

Deputy PM Najib Tun Razak

A government strategy to lift the majority Malays out of poverty has ensured discounts on housing, quotas for civil service jobs, and places at university for the bumiputera, the “sons of the soil”.

Malaysia is riding high on an oil-fuelled boom.

Ethnic Indians see Malays enjoy the spoils of political domination and the Chinese reap economic rewards.

They feel left behind, and some are demanding change.

The men who organised the march in Kuala Lumpur six weeks ago are in prison now.

They were arrested and detained indefinitely under stringent security laws, having been deemed a threat to national security.

“It’s a very delicate situation in Malaysia,” the country’s deputy prime minister told me when I interviewed him last weekend.

In a blunt assessment of the fragility of the ethnic mix here, Najib Tun Razak said: “The underlying problems that we have can easily erupt between the communities.”

As for the demonstration, illegal under Malaysian law, he said: “If we allow street demonstrations to take place on a regular basis, it will in fact entice or aggravate other sections of the community who want to respond to it.”

There is a history of racial violence in Malaysia. In one incident in 2001, six men died in a week of clashes between Malays and Malaysian Indians in an area west of Kuala Lumpur called Kampung Medang.

It started when a man kicked over a chair as he passed a wedding celebration.

Some of the victims were hacked to death.

International message

Water cannon spray protesters in Kuala Lumpur  (10/11/2007)

The government has made it clear it will not tolerate more protests

With a general election approaching, there is a fear, even an expectation among some, that the clashes in Kampung Medang could be repeated.

I have walked around the new estate which has since risen up to replace the squats in the Kampung Medang.

One simple image conveys the divide.

On one side of a road, running through the low-rise tower blocks, I saw a Malaysian Indian making roti – thin fried bread – in a restaurant.

On the other side of the road, a Malay man was chopping chicken to order as a Malay woman in a headscarf selected fish from an ice-packed polystyrene box.

They live side by side but most people will tell you that they do not share their lives.

I interviewed one of the men who organised the protest in November just before he was arrested.

P Uthayakumar said the public demonstrations would go on.

“What else can we do?” he said. “We’ve exhausted all avenues.”

The government has made it clear it will not tolerate any more marches. The organisers are locked up, indefinitely.

The decision to tighten visa controls for Indian workers wishing to come here was a message sent on the international stage but to a domestic audience – along the lines of: “Stop what you are doing or we will make life difficult for your friends and relatives seeking to join you”.

As Malaysia prepares to elect a new government, the stakes are high.

Malaysia is oil-rich and developing quickly. Stability is the key.

At the moment, Malaysia is in a rare state of instability.


Technorati Tags: ,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: