The Star says:-
Hillcrest HM denies segregation
KUALA LUMPUR: SMK Hillcrest in Gombak has never practised segregation, said principal Nik Maryam Idris.
“Our students are not segregated in class. But after assembly and during recess, they are asked to use separate staircases,” she said at the school.
This, she added, had been practised since the school opened in 1991.
“Boys can be a bit rough sometimes and we just want to ensure the safety of the female students,” she said.
She said students were not punished if they used the wrong staircase.
“Although they don’t have to use separate staircases at other times, many of the students continue to do so,” she added.
The school has 2,217 students in Forms One to Five, she said, adding that it won the award for best academic programme among Gombak schools in 2006 and 2007.
SMK Hillcrest parent-teacher association (PTA) president Mohamed Isa Hamzah confirmed that the issue of segregation had never been brought up at PTA meetings.
“The PTA wouldn’t agree to something like this. Three of my children have been educated at the school. My youngest child, who is now at the school, has also never complained about segregation,” he said.
It was reported on Sunday that male and female students had to sit separately in class and in the canteen.
The Education Ministry’s Schools Division director Zulkifly Mohd Wazir said he had not received any complaint about the school.
Education director-general Datuk Alimuddin Mohd Dom said last week that the ministry did not have a policy of segregating boys and girls.
It is very simple, there is partial segregation. After assembly and during recess students use separate staircases. The reason, boys are rough and the safety of the girls is important.
What a load of rubbish. In the first place, where did the Principal Nik Maryam Idris learn part segregation of this nature solves the problem. Maybe she can quote authorities so that other Principals follow. Boys are undisciplined, what has she done to correct this. What has happened to the Disciplinary Teacher, or is there none in this school. How many stairs are there in the school, and for a start can some teachers stand near the stairs to ensure boys behave well. Or are the teachers intimated by the boys.
PTA President is a gem. He reminds me of the 3 monkeys not seeing, hearing or looking. This Presidency is a responsible delegation and if he is waiting for input just from his children to know what is happening at the school, it is good he reconsider his position and allow others to be the President. Obviously, the work load is heavy.
There is no smoke without fire. Segregation is done it was reported in the classroom and canteen. Somebody is dousing the fire.
Education Director-general may have to issue a statement that partial segregation is not allowed. Then we have 1/2, 3/4, 3.8 segregation. His statement must cover all such types of segregation.